Get the knowledge you need to make well-informed financial decisions at our upcoming events. Register now.

Loading...

Should you give kids cash for Christmas?

2018-12-23T15:00:18+10:00

Does giving cash lack Christmas spirit?

This article is published by Modoras Pty Ltd ABN 86 068 034 908

Giving Kids cash for Christmas. Is it lazy? Or a lesson?

Kids given cash for Christmas may make poor purchasing choices if not supervised. Source: Adobe stock

Kids given cash for Christmas may make poor purchasing choices if not supervised. Source: Adobe stock

For many time-poor parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles or godparents, the option of giving cash at Christmas is a godsend. Cash is easy to organise, cheap to post, and gives the added gifts of freedom and choice to the recipient. Family members living overseas or interstate can achieve legendary status by sending cash to hard-to-please child relations without fear of getting it wrong. But be careful, there are downsides to giving cash too. Unsupervised Christmas cash gifts will be quickly spent on low value items that won’t be appreciated. Give kids cash, but with care.

Does giving cash lack Christmas spirit?

In a 2014 article for news.com, child psychologist Michael Carr-Gregg came out firmly against giving cash for Christmas1. He even went so far as to say it is “without Christmas spirit”. Harsh? We think so. He softened his comments by saying cash gifts that came without education on money management and saving were the main problem. In the same article, consumer expert Christopher Zinn worried that small kids given cash would fritter it away at the shops, buying low value items which would be quickly lost or broken. He was also concerned that kids given cash and left to their own devices wouldn’t understand the value of money. The piece went on to cite research by Roy Morgan on kid’s spending habits. It found that girls liked to spend their money on toys and clothes, while boys preferred console games. Both girls and boys said they would also put gift money in their bank account.

Giving cash avoids disappointment and waste

A British article from The Guardian explores the other side of the argument, coming down strongly in favour of cash gifts as the BEST present you can give to kids. It says giving cash avoids the thousands of unwanted presents given and received every year. No more wrong colours or sizes, no age inappropriate presents and no more dodgy re-gifts. Giving cash removes all possibility of error, making it the best possible present (and it’s easy to post!). The article also favours cash gifts as a prime opportunity to teach kids the value of saving money to buy a larger item2.

Like it or not, giving cash is a growing habit among Australian families. A Roy Morgan survey in 2013 found that 66% of kids aged 6-13 would receive cash for Christmas. That number was up 4% from 2007 and we imagine it’s even higher in 2016. The average amount received was $85, and 38% of kids received $100 or more3. It’s time to accept that cash is a common gift for kids. Instead of complaining about it, focus on providing a sound financial education so they understand how to value it and spend it wisely.

Turning cash gifts into future financial security

We have written an e-book called Money Savvy Habits for Kids4. It’s an easy to read, practical guide to teaching your kids the value of money. It recommends that parents teach kids to have fun with their cash presents and spend a little, but to also actively save for their future. Money put aside each time a child receives cash, invested wisely, can be the price of a car or an airline ticket by the time they’re old enough to appreciate these things.

It even suggests saving a portion of each cash gift until it reaches the minimum price of a share package. Kids can choose which blue chip company to invest in, they can keep an eye on the price and bank the dividends, saving for the next parcel of shares. This is a far more interesting and interactive savings tool than a term deposit or a piggy bank that sits temptingly on the bookshelf. From a young age, kids can be involved in their own financial future. You can teach them exactly how good it feels to reach a saving milestone, or watch the value of their own share portfolio climb.

Teaching your kids about cash and make them financially savvy from a young age Source: Unsplash/Jon Flobrant

Teaching your kids about cash and make them financially savvy from a young age Source: Unsplash/Jon Flobrant

No more guilt, give cash and start their financial education

Giving cash as a Christmas gift should not be a guilt sodden experience. And if you’re a far-away grandparent or other relative, it could be your best option. But even if you live around the corner, cash as a Christmas gift is still ok. Any grumpy teenager will tell you it’s the best kind of gift. So, if you’re the parent (or even the grandparent) of a kid with a wad of Christmas cash, take the opportunity to teach them about money and the importance of saving. Encourage them to save a decent portion of every gift for a future purchase (or just for their future). Just as you must assemble the Barbie dream house or help with the Lego spaceship, you must be involved in how cash gifts are valued, spent and saved. That’s the trick to making cash a successful (and guilt-free) Christmas gift.

Any questions about how to begin your kid’s financial education? We can help. Call Modoras on 1300 888 803.

Over to you

Do you think it’s ok to give kids cash for Christmas? Or do you think it lacks Christmas spirit? Is it ever too early to start educating kids about finance?

Sources:

1. News.com: 9 out of 10 kids receive lazy cash gifts for Christmas – Dec 2014
2. The Guardian: Cash is the best Christmas present for kids – Dec 2014
3. Roy Morgan survey on cash gifts to kids – 2013
4. 
Emily Hein- Money Savvy Habits for Kids – eBook

Testimonials

“There are things I must do in the next five years to make that happen, but I know what they are and am working towards them. This is a much happier prospect than what I believed would be my lot when I reached retirement age.”

Scharlaine

“I will remain with them as they have been great to me for many many years.”

Sharn

“I’ve been a customer for several decades(scary how time flies). The service has always been impeccable, consistent, friendly.”

Colleen

“Very happy with the ease of experience. And extremely happy with my return…much more than I anticipated.”

Angela

“The process suits me perfectly, the details and everything you need from me is provided. You then review and I come in to sign where appropriate. In a busy schedule, it suits me perfectly.”

Richard

“Our business with Modoras is always very professional and friendly making it a pleasure to attend.”

Peter & Merle

“I have recommended Modoras to friends and family. My sister in law is now a client.”

Glenn

“Professional service with the personal care factor.”

Kathy

“We are very happy with the service that Modoras have provided and find all staff very friendly and helpful.”

Tom

“Super friendly staff . Would recommend and have recommended.”

Danielle

“We really enjoy the hospitality every time we visit the office, to meet and talk directly with the ‘Modoras family’ has a huge impact in entrusting our financial future.”

Robert

“We have built an excellent business rapport with our Accountant over many, many years. He has managed both personal and business tax and accounting matters for us. It is a pleasure to attend the lovely office in Mt Gravatt. The Reception staff are friendly and efficient. AND they make a great coffee!”

Rosemary

Financial Planning and Credit services are offered through Modoras Pty Ltd ABN 86 068 034 908. Australian Financial Services and Credit Licence No. 233209.
Accounting services are offered through Modoras Accounting (QLD) Pty Ltd ABN 81 601 145 215, Modoras Accounting (VIC) Pty Ltd ACN 145 368 850 and Modoras Accounting (SYD) Pty Ltd ABN 18 622 475 521

Copyright Modoras 2018. All Rights Reserved.

PHP Code Snippets Powered By : XYZScripts.com